Lamenting Liberty Lost – Andrew Napolitano

A British author, residing in the United States for the past 30 years, created a small firestorm earlier this week with his candid observations that modern-day Americans have been duped by the government into accepting a European-style march toward socialism because we fail to appreciate the rich legacy of personal liberty that is everyone’s birthright and is expressly articulated in the Declaration of Independence and guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution.

English: Detail of Preamble to Constitution of...

Os Guinness, the author of more than a dozen books defending traditional Judeo-Christian values and Jeffersonian personal liberty, argued that we should embrace individual liberty and personal dignity and reject the “no givens, no rules, no limits” government we now have. He went on to opine that the government today is not the constitutionally restrained protector of personal freedoms the Framers left us, but rather has become the wealth-distributing protector of collective interests the Founding Fathers never could have imagined.

Yet the problem is a deep one. The Framers believed in the presumption of liberty, which declares that we are free to make personal choices, and the government cannot interfere with our liberties unless we violate the rights of others. Stated differently, the federal government cannot interfere with our personal choices by writing any law it wants; it can only regulate behavior or spend money when the Constitution authorizes it to do so.

But for the past 100 years, the federal government has rejected the Madisonian concept that it is limited to the 16 discrete powers the Constitution delegates to it, and has claimed its powers are unlimited, subject only to the express prohibitions in the Constitution. Even those prohibitions can be gotten around since government lawyers have persuaded federal courts to rule that Congress can spend tax dollars or borrowed money on any projects it wishes, whether authorized by the Constitution or not. The courts even have authorized Congress to use federal tax dollars to bribe the states into enacting laws that Congress is powerless to enact, and Congress has done so.

The Declaration of Independence defines our personal liberties as inalienable aspects of our humanity, and the Constitution prohibits the government from interfering with those liberties—like thought, speech, press, association, worship, self-defense, travel, privacy, due process, use of money, and private property, to name a few.

The teaching of these founding documents is that our liberties are natural—their source is not the government—and they are personal, not collective. We don’t need a government permission slip to exercise them; we don’t need to belong to a group to enjoy them; they cannot be taken away by a congressional vote or a presidential signature.

Read the rest via Lamenting Liberty Lost –

3 thoughts on “Lamenting Liberty Lost – Andrew Napolitano

  1. Joe Jarvis January 8, 2015 / 1:07 PM

    Exactly. I love what the Bill of Rights says, but unfortunately the Constitution has either authorized the government we have, or has been powerless to resist it. That, and realizing a government has never stayed limited, has pushed me more towards anarchism. I truly think people would be able to organize themselves just fine without the government, and the results would be a better world in every objective way.


    • Thomas Hill January 8, 2015 / 1:54 PM

      Well said, Joe. I stand with Lysander Spooner in regards to the US Constitution. However, I can imagine how much better it would be had “We The People” held the federal government to the constitutional standards it claims to abide by.

      Thank you for your comments.


      Thomas Hill


      • Joe Jarvis January 8, 2015 / 1:57 PM

        Absolutely. We would be living in a much better world if the states had maintained control over the federal government.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s